Document Key
Windows 10 & 11 Buy license · $29.95
Windows built-in tools

EFS vs BitLocker: Which Windows Encryption Should You Use?

EFS vs BitLocker compared: what each encrypts, which Windows editions have them, how they protect a stolen PC, and when you need file encryption as well.

Updated 5 minute read The Document Key team

EFS and BitLocker are both built into Windows Pro, Enterprise and Education, but they protect against different things. BitLocker encrypts an entire drive, so a lost or stolen PC, or a removed disk, reveals nothing. EFS (Encrypting File System) encrypts chosen files and folders and ties them to your Windows account, so other users on the same PC cannot open them. Neither one asks for a password when you open a file, and neither keeps files encrypted when you email them or copy them elsewhere. For most people, BitLocker is the one to turn on first; EFS is a useful extra on shared PCs.

Here is a side-by-side comparison and the situations where each one helps, or does not.

Side-by-side comparison

BitLockerEFS
What it encryptsWhole drives (system, data, USB)Individual files and folders
Windows editionsPro, Enterprise, Education (Home has Device Encryption)Pro, Enterprise, Education
Drive formatsNTFS, FAT32, exFATNTFS only
Unlocks withTPM at startup, optional PIN, or a password for data drivesYour Windows sign-in
Protects a stolen, powered-off PCYesPartly: files are encrypted, but keys are tied to your sign-in
Protects from other users on the PCNo, once unlockedYes
Protects copies you email or uploadNoNo
Recovery method48-digit recovery keyExported certificate or recovery agent

How BitLocker works

BitLocker encrypts every sector of a drive. On a typical laptop, the key is held by the TPM chip and released only when the PC boots normally with its expected firmware and startup files. You sign in to Windows as usual and notice nothing. If someone removes the drive or tries to boot something else, the data stays encrypted. By default Windows uses XTS-AES with a 128-bit key for BitLocker drives, and administrators can choose 256-bit through policy.

For extra protection, Pro users can add a startup PIN so the drive does not unlock without it. Removable drives can be encrypted with BitLocker To Go and unlocked with a password.

The limit is that once Windows is running, the drive is unlocked. Anyone using your session, any program running as you, and anything you copy off the drive sees normal, unencrypted files.

Windows 11 Home does not include full BitLocker, but supported PCs have Device Encryption, which encrypts the internal drives automatically. See BitLocker on Windows 11 Home for what that does and does not cover.

How EFS works

EFS encrypts individual files on NTFS drives. When you tick Encrypt contents to secure data in a file or folder's Advanced Attributes, Windows encrypts the file with a random key and protects that key with a certificate belonging to your user account. When you are signed in, the file opens normally. When another user tries to open it, they get access denied, even if they have permission to the folder.

EFS has a few important behaviors:

  • It does not travel. Copy an EFS file to a FAT32 or exFAT USB stick, attach it to an email, or upload it through a browser, and the copy is decrypted.
  • It depends on your certificate. Reinstall Windows, move the drive to a new PC, or have an administrator reset your password, and you can lose access unless you exported the certificate. See EFS files access denied after reinstall.
  • It needs NTFS and a Pro edition. If the checkbox is unavailable, see why Encrypt contents to secure data is grayed out.

Which threats each one stops

SituationBitLockerEFS
Laptop stolen while shut downProtectedProtected, if your Windows password is strong
Laptop stolen while asleep and unlocked behind the lock screenWeaker; the drive is unlocked in memoryWeaker, for the same reason
Another family member's account on the same PCNot protectedProtected
Someone uses your PC while you are signed inNot protectedNot protected
Malware running under your accountNot protectedNot protected
File emailed or copied to USBNot protectedNot protected

Using them together

EFS and BitLocker work fine side by side. A sensible Windows Pro setup is BitLocker on the system drive, with a recovery key saved somewhere safe, plus EFS on folders that other accounts on the PC should not see. BitLocker covers the stolen-laptop case; EFS covers the shared-PC case.

That still leaves the gaps both share: files you send, files you copy to USB or cloud, and files anyone can open while you are signed in. Those need encryption that is tied to a password rather than to the drive or your Windows account. Our guide to file encryption vs full disk encryption explains why many people use both kinds.

Where a password-based tool fits

Password-based file encryption fills the gaps that EFS and BitLocker leave. Document Key encrypts files and folders with AES-256 and a password you choose, on any edition of Windows 10 or 11 including Home. The files ask for the password each time, stay encrypted when you copy them to a USB drive or cloud folder, and can be sent as encrypted share packages. Auto-lock closes folders and vaults when you are idle, the PC sleeps or you sign out, which covers the "signed in and walked away" case, and a recovery key protects you from a forgotten password.

Which should you use?

  • Every laptop: BitLocker or Device Encryption, with the recovery key saved away from the PC.
  • Shared PC with separate accounts on Pro: add EFS for private folders, and export your EFS certificate.
  • Files you share, carry or store in the cloud: password-based file encryption, because neither EFS nor BitLocker stays with the file.
  • Windows Home: Device Encryption if your PC supports it, plus a file encryption tool for anything sensitive.

Performance and day-to-day impact

On modern PCs, neither tool slows everyday work noticeably. Processors include instructions that speed up AES, and SSDs are fast enough that the extra work rarely shows. BitLocker's initial encryption of a full drive can take a while, but you can keep using the PC while it runs. EFS adds a little work each time an encrypted file is opened or saved, which is only noticeable with very large numbers of files. Document Key works the same way: encryption happens when you lock files, and opening a file is a double-click and your password.

Whichever you choose, the recovery details are what save you when something goes wrong. Save the BitLocker recovery key, export the EFS certificate, and keep any encryption app's recovery key, all somewhere other than the PC itself.

Frequently asked questions

Can I use EFS and BitLocker together?

Yes. BitLocker protects the whole drive if the PC is lost or stolen, and EFS adds per-user protection for chosen files while Windows is running.

Does BitLocker protect files when I am signed in?

No. Once Windows has started and the drive is unlocked, files are readable by anyone using your account and by malware running as you.

Which is better for a USB drive?

BitLocker To Go, because EFS is tied to your Windows account and only works on NTFS drives. Creating BitLocker To Go drives needs Pro, Enterprise or Education.

Get three guides like this every month, plus software update notices.Subscribe →